Monday, August 16, 2010


Stars: Julia Roberts, Richard Jenkins, James Franco, Viola Davis, Billy Crudup, Javier Bardem
Director: Ryan Murphy
Genre: Adventure/drama

Ryan Murphy directs Julia Roberts and a capable cast in the screen adaptation of author Elizabeth Gilbert's 2006 bestseller, Eat, Pray, Love--wherein the writer sets off on a year long quest to find enlightenment, romance, and great Italian pizza.

Bored with her marriage to Steve, (Billy Crudup) Liz files for divorce and takes up with a young actor (James Franco) who whets her appetite for spirituality--unwittingly sewing the seeds of his own demise with the flighty wordsmith--who seems to burn out quickly on guys who really care for her.
So she's off to Italy, where she'll engage in philosophical discourse with her new acquaintances while stuffing her face a lot; then to India where she hangs out in an ashram, looking like she's always feeling slightly out of her depth; and finally to Bali, to soak up wisdom from a toothless medicine man and get involved with a Brazilian dude--another nebulous relationship--because she's never quite sure about anything.

And now to my biggest pet-peeve about films that are adapted from nonfiction: The central character is always played by someone who is noticeably better looking than the real person. (Unless it's like, Ernest Borgnine.) So that is the first thing that gets fictionalized when a nonfiction book hits the silver screen. Liz Gilbert is a reasonably attractive woman, but she's no Julia Roberts. However, when I read the book some years back, I got the distinct impression that the author thought of herself as being this super hot chick, so she must have figured the selection of Ms. Roberts to play her was spot on.

Richard Jenkins' performance as the down-home Texas dude who befriends Liz at the ashram in India, dispensing nuggets of wisdom as he deals with the spectre of his own past, is already being touted as Oscar worthy, and I agree. And Javier Bardem as Felipe, Gilbert's love interest in the latter part of the film, is an affable presence, and sure-fire swoon material for this chik-flick's primary audience--though I think that Eat, Pray, Love does have broader appeal than that--if for no other reason than there's been a ton of hype about it, and guys will inevitably get dragged into the theatre at the behest of their girlfriends and spouses.

Now, how shall I describe the soundtrack? Well, it's one of the most curious, surprising, delightful, and baffling amalgamations of sound accompanying a major film in recent memory. From breezy samba rhythms, to Sly and the Family Stone, Kool and the Gang, Neil Young, and something that nearly made me fall out of my seat...a piece lifted right from Gato Barbieri's exquisite soundtrack from Last Tango In Paris. Never have I seen such a blatant recycling of something so wholly identifiable--for all time--with one particular movie, and a classic at that. I was delighted, (to hear it) yet cringing at the same time, as the melody that originally accompanied graceful tango dancers gliding across the floor was now being set to the image of Julia Roberts stuffing her face with pizza! BALLSY--I'll give them credit for that.

There's gorgeous cinematography--which you might expect considering the locales they had to work with--but Eat, Pray, Love suffers from some choppy editing. Had some of those scenic shots been held just a second or two longer, it would have given the film more of a seamless feel. As it is, it looks like the editor was rushing to finish. (The movie runs about two and a half hours.)
Non-fiction brought to the screen often feels rather plotless--we're so conditioned to those traditional story arcs--but there is growth and transformation here, so if you've got the time and the bucks to spend a year galavanting about the globe, you too may gain some insight into who you are. But unless you can write a blockbuster bestseller about your experiences, that may be a jobless schmuck who is flat broke.



  1. Mmmm Pizza.

    I read the book. It was okay I suppose but I don't care to see the film. My reasons for hesitation are pretty much what you've outlined here.

    One film I AM looking forward to is Despicable Me. I heart Steve Carell.

  2. CLAIRE,
    One vote for Despicable I may have to see it and post a review!

  3. Great review but am so discouraged don't know if i will go see it..

    Usually, if I give a film at least a "B" rating, that means I think it's worth seeing. Though there are obvious flaws, I felt that I could live with them. :)

  5. thanks for stopping by my blog today, friend!

  6. Timoteo,
    Julia does make the movies better even if the plot is so-so... I haven't seen this one, but I'll probably get PPV. Great review!

  7. EMILY,
    And a nice blog you have there...

    Yes, but you're looking at everything through the filter of a broken heart...get well soon! :)

    Always good to hear from you!

  8. i was really, really disappointed in this movie.

    i had high hopes. just felt like it was lacking something.

  9. Hey BRIT,
    Maybe it was all the pre-release hype--building the expectations for this film, and then the reality being a letdown. Kinda like Christmas, for many people. :)

  10. watching the movie made me realize how much I had forgotten about the book and made me want to read it again - I'm a sucker for ms roberts so I enjoyed it well enough!

  11. ELSIEE,
    I enjoyed the book more than the movie--the film was worth watching--but there is so much more insight into the personality of Elizabeth in the book...big surprise, eh?

  12. Hi Timoteo, Nice blog & good post. overall You have beautifully maintained it, you must try this website which really helps to increase your traffic. hope u have a wonderful day & awaiting for more new post. Keep Blogging!